My neighbor Robert has a flock of lovely hens and a couple of mean ol’ roosters who work those ladies hard. Too hard. The roosters had to go, and one of them came to me — live, in a large box.
I’d never cooked a rooster before, and I was more than curious.
It fell to my son to reach a swift hand into the box and grab that rooster by the feet. He quickly swung the bird onto the counter, on top of a long sheet of plastic wrap, holding the wing against the bird’s body. I reached over to hold down the bird’s wing, and we wrapped that bird in a snug Saran wrap blanket. We’ve done this before. It is a good way to immobilize a bird if you don’t have a cone.
Then outside went Sam and the bird and . . .
Back in the kitchen (it was minus 6°F outside), we scalded the bird in my 5-gallon stock pot and placed it in a large plastic bin. In minutes we plucked that bird clean as we marveled at its long, narrow anatomy and beautiful feathers. Back onto the sanitized counter, and Sam eviscerated the bird. I gave it a good wash in the sink, patted it dry, and bagged it.
Take your time with roosters, and they are more than worth eating, as are older birds. Roosters differ from older hens in that their bones are larger and sturdier (harder to cut) with more cartilage and denser muscles. Also the breasts are much smaller, and there is a greater proportion of dark meat. But the cooking rules are the same.
- Let the bird age in the refrigerator for 2 to 4 days. You can keep it in a container of water or just wrapped in plastic (after washing and drying well).
- Marinate for at least 12 and up to 48 hours, if you are planning to eat the meat. This isn’t necessary if you are simply making stock.
Rooster in marinade
- Cook long and slow. In a Dutch oven with a lid, cook at 200°F for at least 6 hours, or until the meat is falling off the bone. The manual for my slow cooker says High equals 212°F, Low equals 200°F, Simmer equals 185°F, and Keep Warm equals 165°F. If you are going to use a slow cooker, it is worth checking to make sure that Low is the proper temperature for your slow cooker; many run higher than that.
- Old birds vary! This is not a standardized piece of meat. Do not plan to serve the day you are cooking the bird, unless you plan to start very, very early in the morning. Far safer is to cook the bird a day in advance and give it as much time as it requires to become tender. Then skim off the fat, reheat, and serve.
Parslied potatoes were the perfect accompaniment. I’ve never enjoyed a better coq au vin, and it was so satisfying to know that I was turning a mean old rooster into a dish that was created with just that in mind.
Classic coq au vin served with parslied potatoes
Andrea Chesman is the author of many cookbooks, including The Pickled Pantry, Recipes from the Root Cellar, Pickles and Relishes, Mom’s Best One-Dish Suppers, and The Vegetarian Grill, which was nominated for a James Beard Foundation Book Award and won a National Barbecue Association Award of Excellence. She is a coauthor of 250 Treasured Country Desserts and The Classic Zucchini Cookbook, and her articles have appeared in the New York Times, Cooking Light, Food & Wine, Vegetarian Times, Organic Gardening, Fine Cooking, and other publications.